Swensen's Hot Fudge Sauce Copycat Recipe
Cream, sugar, cocoa and butter, boiled briefly. Five minutes, and it turns any supermarket vanilla into a dessert.
Peppermint Extract, Chopped Chocolate, and No Green Colouring
Mint choc chip with chocolate that snaps rather than sticks.
AI-generated illustration created for food.fast. It is not photographic evidence of a prepared batch.
Two things separate a good mint chocolate chip from a disappointing one, and neither is the mint. The first is the form the chocolate takes. The second is which mint flavouring you use.
Chocolate chips are engineered to hold their shape in a hot oven, which they do by carrying less cocoa butter and more stabiliser. Frozen, that makes them waxy and they stay waxy in the mouth. Hand-chopped dark chocolate shatters into irregular shards that melt as you eat them.
For the mint, extract rather than essence. Essence is usually synthetic and tastes of toothpaste at the back; extract is distilled from the plant and tastes of mint.
The method gives quantities, timings and observable cues rather than asking you to guess. The 3 cases in If it goes wrong explain likely causes and corrective action.
See the recipe verification standard · See how the cost is calculated
Chop a bar with a long knife on a board, working from one corner in a rocking motion. You want a mix of sizes: some shards the size of a fingernail, some dust.
The dust matters. It disperses through the base and gives a faint background of chocolate everywhere, which is what stops the flavour being a series of isolated hits.
Use chocolate at 60 to 70 per cent cocoa solids. Milk chocolate is too sweet against an already sweet base, and anything above 80 turns chalky when frozen.
The colour is entirely cosmetic and entirely added. Mint leaves contribute no green to an extract, so a green ice cream has had colouring put in.
Left alone the base is off-white with dark flecks, which is what the "white mint" version on most menus looks like. If you want the colour, a single drop of green food colouring is enough - two makes it look synthetic, which rather defeats the point of using a real extract.
Work from a corner of the bar with a long knife, rocking rather than pressing. Aim for a mix of fingernail-sized pieces and fine dust - the dust flavours the whole base.
About 6 minStir half the peppermint extract and the salt into the condensed milk, then taste. Mint strength varies a great deal between bottles; add the rest only if it needs it.
About 3 minCold cream, whipped until it just holds a peak that flops at the tip. Stop there or it will not fold in cleanly.
About 4 minBeat a third of the cream into the condensed milk to loosen it, fold in the rest, then fold the chopped chocolate through with the last few turns so it stays suspended.
About 4 minScrape into a metal tin, press paper onto the surface and freeze until firm. Overnight is better than six hours if you can wait.
About 6 hrEach entry names a likely cause as well as a correction, so the advice remains useful when equipment, ingredients or batch size differ.
The recipes that go with this one, or that use what you have just made.
Cream, sugar, cocoa and butter, boiled briefly. Five minutes, and it turns any supermarket vanilla into a dessert.
A proper hot fudge sauce - thick, glossy and made with cocoa and butter - over ice cream. Eight minutes for the sauce.
Four parts ice cream to one part milk, blended briefly. Ninety seconds, and the only real mistake is over-blending.