food.fast Takeaway taste, kitchen prices
What are you spending?

  1. Home
  2. Copycat recipes
  3. Sauces & dips
  4. Papa John's Garlic Dipping Sauce Copycat Recipe

How to Make Papa John's Garlic Dipping Sauce at Home

Clarified Garlic Butter, and the Two Minutes That Stop It Separating

The little pot of garlic butter, clear and stable, for about nine pence.

By food.fast editors Published Updated Print
Start cooking — the method What you need 10 min start to finish · serves 8
A small pot of clear golden garlic butter beside a pizza crust and a pepperoncini on a dark board

AI-generated illustration created for food.fast. It is not photographic evidence of a prepared batch.

Prep
2 min
Cook
8 min
Makes
8About ½ cup (120 ml) - eight dip pots
Difficulty
Very easy
Per serving
128 kcal

This is the other great chain dipping sauce, and unlike the Domino's one it genuinely is butter-based. It is also the simplest recipe on this entire site - butter, garlic powder, salt - with one technique that makes the difference between a good result and the real thing.

That technique is clarifying. Butter is roughly 80 per cent fat, 16 per cent water and 4 per cent milk solids. Melt it plain and those solids stay suspended, the sauce looks cloudy, and as it cools they settle out and the whole thing separates into layers in the pot.

Skim them off and you have clarified butter: clear, golden, stable at room temperature, and it keeps for a month rather than a week. It takes an extra four minutes.

How this page shows its working

The method gives quantities, timings and observable cues rather than asking you to guess. The 5 cases in If it goes wrong explain likely causes and corrective action; 1 ingredient note explains choices that materially affect the result.

See the recipe verification standard · See how the cost is calculated

How to clarify butter, which is mostly just watching it

Melt the butter slowly over a low heat and do not stir it. Three layers form:

  1. A white foam on top - whey proteins. Skim this off with a spoon.
  2. Clear golden fat in the middle - this is what you want.
  3. A milky sediment at the bottom - casein and lactose. Leave it behind.

Once the foam has been skimmed and the bubbling has quietened - which means the water has boiled off - pour the clear middle layer carefully into your bowl, stopping when you reach the sediment. A sieve lined with muslin makes this foolproof.

You lose about 20 per cent of the volume. That is why the recipe starts with more butter than the yield suggests.

Take it slightly further and it becomes ghee: keep the heat on until the sediment browns and the butter smells nutty, then strain. This is not the Papa John's flavour - it is browner and nuttier - but it is very good and it is the same technique one minute later.

Unsalted butter, then salt separately

Salted butter varies enormously between brands - anywhere from 1.2% to 2.5% salt - which makes a small batch like this unpredictable. Unsalted butter plus a measured half teaspoon puts you in control.

How to make it, step by step

Make it

  1. Melt the butter slowly and do not stir

    Lowest heat. It will melt, then foam, then start to separate into three visible layers. This takes five or six minutes and cannot be hurried without browning it.

    About 6 min

  2. Skim the white foam off the top

    With a shallow spoon. Take your time - anything you leave will cloud the finished sauce.

    About 1 min

  3. Pour off the clear golden fat, leaving the sediment behind

    Carefully, stopping when you see the milky layer start to move. Or pour everything through muslin, which is easier.

    TipThe sediment is not waste - stir it into mashed potato.
    About 1 min

  4. Whisk in the garlic powder and salt while it is warm

    Warm butter dissolves the powder; cold butter leaves it gritty. Whisk for thirty seconds until completely smooth.

    About 1 min

Serving it warm, and why it sets in the fridge

Butter is solid below about 32 °C, so this sauce is a soft solid in a fridge and a liquid at room temperature. That is correct and it is why the pots come warm.

To serve, take it out twenty minutes ahead or warm it for fifteen seconds in a microwave. Do not boil it - overheated clarified butter separates into oil and a grainy residue, which is difficult to bring back.

It stays liquid at room temperature for hours, which is one of the practical advantages of clarifying. Un-clarified melted butter solidifies unevenly and looks unappealing within twenty minutes.

For a party, a small warmed ceramic pot keeps it right for the evening.

Ways to change it once you have made it once

With fresh garlic, safely

Two crushed cloves simmered in the butter for two minutes and then strained out. The flavour is in the butter and the garlic itself is gone, which removes the food safety question. Keeps two weeks rather than a month.

Garlic and herb

A teaspoon each of dried parsley, oregano and basil whisked in warm.

Chilli garlic

Half a teaspoon of chilli flakes steeped in the warm butter for ten minutes. Excellent on a pizza crust and better on pasta.

What went wrong, and how to fix it

Each entry names a likely cause as well as a correction, so the advice remains useful when equipment, ingredients or batch size differ.

It is cloudy
Why it happened
The milk solids were not removed.
What to do
Remelt it gently, let it settle for five minutes, and pour off the clear layer.
It separated into layers in the pot
Why it happened
Same cause - unclarified butter separates as it cools.
What to do
Clarify it. That is what the technique is for.
It is gritty
Why it happened
Garlic powder added to cool butter.
What to do
Warm it and whisk. Add the powder while the butter is hot.
It tastes burnt or nutty
Why it happened
The heat was too high and the sediment browned.
What to do
It is now ghee, which is a fine thing and not this. Lower heat next time.
It went rancid within a fortnight
Why it happened
Milk solids left in, or stored in light.
What to do
Properly clarified butter keeps a month. The solids are what spoil.

Questions people actually ask about this recipe

Why clarify the butter?
The milk solids cloud the sauce, make it separate as it cools and shorten its life from a week to a month. Skimming them off takes four minutes.
Can I use fresh garlic?
Only if you simmer it and strain it out. Fresh garlic left sitting in butter at room temperature is a genuine botulism risk.
Why does it go solid in the fridge?
It is butter. Twenty minutes at room temperature or fifteen seconds in a microwave brings it back.
How long does it keep?
A month in the fridge, properly clarified. The milk solids are what spoil, and they have been removed.

Make these next

The recipes that go with this one, or that use what you have just made.

All recipes →