Papa John's
Papa John's Garlic Dipping Sauce Copycat Recipe
Butter with the milk solids skimmed off, garlic powder and salt. Six minutes, and the skimming is what keeps it clear…
How to Make Domino's Garlic and Herb Dip at Home
The Garlic and Herb Dip: Mayonnaise, Not Butter, and Powder Not Fresh
The little pot, for eight pence instead of a pound, in four minutes.
AI-generated illustration created for food.fast. It is not photographic evidence of a prepared batch.
Ask anybody in the UK or Ireland what they actually order from Domino's and the honest answer involves a small plastic pot of garlic and herb dip. People buy extra ones. People have been known to order a pizza mainly as a vehicle for it.
It is also one of the most commonly botched copycat recipes on the internet, and there are two specific reasons. The first is that a lot of recipes build it on melted butter, presumably by analogy with garlic bread. It is a mayonnaise emulsion - cold, thick and stable - and butter gives you something that separates as it cools.
The second is fresh garlic. Fresh garlic in a cold acidic emulsion tastes harsh and raw, it gets stronger and more sulphurous over a day, and it carries a genuine botulism risk in an oil-based mixture kept at room temperature. Garlic powder is what the commercial product uses and it is what makes the flavour round rather than sharp.
How this page shows its working
The method gives quantities, timings and observable cues rather than asking you to guess. The 4 cases in If it goes wrong explain likely causes and corrective action; 1 ingredient note explains choices that materially affect the result.
See the recipe verification standard · See how the cost is calculated
Why garlic powder rather than fresh, in more detail than you expected
Three separate reasons, and all three point the same way.
Flavour. Fresh garlic's characteristic sharpness comes from allicin, formed when the cells are broken. In a cold sauce it stays sharp and slightly metallic and it builds over the following day until it dominates. Garlic powder is dehydrated garlic where much of that has already converted to milder sulphur compounds, giving a rounder, sweeter, more diffuse garlic flavour - which is what the dip actually tastes of.
Texture. Crushed fresh garlic leaves fibrous fragments that you feel on the tongue. Powder dissolves completely.
Safety. Garlic is a low-acid vegetable that grows in soil, and Clostridium botulinum spores are common on it. In an oil-based mixture held at room temperature, those spores have exactly the oxygen-free environment they need. This is why commercially bottled garlic-in-oil is acidified and why home garlic oils are a recognised food safety hazard. A mayonnaise dip is acidic enough to be fine in the fridge, but the powder removes the question entirely.
If you want fresh garlic anyway, use one small clove, crushed to a paste with a pinch of salt, alongside - not instead of - the powder, and eat the dip within three days.
Half a teaspoon of sugar, which everyone leaves out
It is not enough to make the dip sweet and it is enough to round off the vinegar and the raw edge of the garlic powder. Leave it out and the dip tastes slightly harsh in a way that is difficult to diagnose. This is the single most common reason a home version is not quite right.
How to make it, step by step
Make it
-
Fold everything together in one bowl
Mayonnaise first, everything else on top. Fold with a spatula until evenly flecked with green. Twenty or thirty turns.
TipNo whisk. Air makes a mayonnaise emulsion pale and foamy.About 3 min -
Two hours in the fridge, minimum
The garlic powder and the dried herbs need to hydrate. Fresh from the bowl it tastes dusty and slightly sharp; two hours later it is the dip.
About 2 hr
Everything it goes with, which is more than pizza crusts
It was designed for pizza crusts and it is one of the most generally useful things in a fridge:
- Chips and wedges, which is what most of a batch actually gets used for.
- Chicken wings, where it works like a ranch.
- As a sandwich spread, particularly with chicken.
- Thinned with a tablespoon of water as a salad dressing.
- Dough balls, which are on this site and are a better vehicle for it than a pizza crust.
It is also the base of a very quick potato salad - three tablespoons folded through warm boiled new potatoes.
What it costs against the pots
| This recipe | Bought | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per pot | £0.08 | £1.00 |
| Time to make eight | 4 minutes | - |
| Keeps | 10 days | - |
| Cost of a pot a week for a year | £4.06 | £52.00 |
Ways to change it once you have made it once
Thinner, as a drizzle
Add 2 tbsp of buttermilk. Good over a whole pizza rather than for dipping.
Herb-heavy
Double the parsley and add a tablespoon of chopped chives. Closer to a ranch and very good on wings.
Vegan
Vegan mayonnaise and unsweetened plant yoghurt in place of the soured cream. Add an extra pinch of salt.
What went wrong, and how to fix it
Each entry names a likely cause as well as a correction, so the advice remains useful when equipment, ingredients or batch size differ.
It tastes dusty
- Why it happened
- The garlic powder and dried herbs have not hydrated.
- What to do
- Two hours in the fridge. It is not a fault, it is a wait.
Harsh and sharp
- Why it happened
- Fresh garlic, or the sugar was left out.
- What to do
- Garlic powder, and half a teaspoon of sugar. Both.
Too thick to dip into
- Why it happened
- Not enough soured cream.
- What to do
- A tablespoon of buttermilk or milk, folded in. It should coat a crust without clinging in a lump.
It separated
- Why it happened
- Low-fat mayonnaise, or it was frozen.
- What to do
- Full-fat mayonnaise, and never freeze it.
Questions people actually ask about this recipe
Is Domino's garlic and herb dip mayonnaise based?
Yes. Its published ingredient list is led by rapeseed oil and water with egg - which describes a mayonnaise. Butter-based copies are working from a wrong assumption.
Can I use fresh garlic?
It tastes harsh, it strengthens over a day, and garlic in oil at room temperature carries a genuine botulism risk. Powder is what the original uses and it is the right answer.
Why does mine taste dusty?
It has not rested. Two hours in the fridge and the powders hydrate.
How long does it keep?
Ten days with garlic powder. Three days if you have added fresh garlic.
Make these next
The recipes that go with this one, or that use what you have just made.
Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut Pan Pizza Copycat Recipe
Three tablespoons of oil in the tin, a dough that proves where it bakes, and a base that fries from underneath. The o…
Domino's Pizza
Domino's Pizza Dough Copycat Recipe
A pressed rather than tossed dough, cold-fermented for two days. Fifteen minutes of work, and the fridge does the rest.
Pizza Express
Pizza Express Dough Balls Copycat Recipe
Walnut-sized, baked hot and fast so they stay pale and pillowy, with a soft garlic butter that melts into them. About…